Muhammad.com collection in 109 languages

  • TheGreatDebateOrRevealingTheTruth, page : 241

4. Mark says that the people who rebuked the woman were
from among the people who were present there at that time,
while Matthew has said that they were the disciples of
Jesus, and John's version is that the objection was raised
by Judas.

5 The three Gospels have quoted Jesus' speech to his dis-
clples on this occasion differently.

The serious contradictions presented by these texts cannot be
eliminated by claiming that this event of Jesus' anointment
might have taken place a number of times, and each gospel
might have reported a different story. The event is clearly the
same in each case and the contradictions in the different

70