Muhammad.com collection in 109 languages

  • Nawawi_10_Ramadan_and_Voluntary_Fasting, page : 76

home or traveling.”

Nisa'i with a chain up to ibn Abbas who related this.

THE PROHIBITION OF MAKING A VOW OF
SILENCE

NO VALUE IN SILENCE FASTING

|H 1851

"I (Ali) preserved in my memory the saying of the Prophet, praise
and peace be upon him, „No one is an orphan after he has come of
age. There is no value in remaining silent from morning until night.‟"

Abu Daud with a chain up to Ali related that the Messenger of Allah, praise and
peace be upon him, said this.

VOW OF SILENCE IS FORBIDDEN